I seem to be on a never ending search for the perfect footwear solution. So far I have tried Asolo Flames, Asolo Sasslongs, Meindl Alaskan Hunters, Meindl Canadian Hunters, Lowa Tibets, Lowa Sheephunters, Lowa Renegades, Lowa Rangers, Hanwag Mountain Lites, and Hanwag Alaskas.
What I archery elk hunted in last year were Inov8 Roclite 315 trail runners. They aren't waterproof, but they dry reasonably fast, and they're very comfortable and make me feel nimble.
The problem with a non-waterproof shoe is managing wet days. I have a trail near the house that I run and hike on all the time, and it has three creek crossings going out and three coming back. Depending on the water level it's mid shin to thigh deep. I've been doing that trail 2-3 times a week for months now, so I'm beginning to get some experience with managing wet shoes.
I think in warmer weather my perfect solution will probably be to take the trail runners with a variety of socks. If it rains, I'll wear a thicker wool sock with a neoprene sock over it to keep my feet warm even though they're wet. Then after it dries out a bit I could change into a thinner wool or synthetic sock to help the shoes dry out quicker (thick wool stays wet a long time). The thinner wool socks dry out quick, and I think that a good synthetic like swiftwick or thorlo would dry out even faster.
Has anyone used the goretex socks by Rocky?
I've also thought about taking two pairs of shoes. A minimalist shoe like a trailroc 235 or xtalon 212 and then the roclite 315's or get a pair of terroc 330's. Then I'd have a cushiony shoe for packing heavy loads, plus a very light shoe for day use. If one pair got soaked I could use the other pair the next day. The two shoe solution would still be lighter than taking my heavy boots.
For colder weather I'd probably prefer my Lowa Sheephunters. I like those boots, but they are heavy and stiff.